Subspace-Based Algorithms for Structural Identification, Damage Detection, and Sensor Data Fusion

1687-6180-2007-069136 1687-6180 Research Article Subspace-Based Algorithms for Structural Identification, Damage Detection, and Sensor Data Fusion BassevilleMichèlemichele.basseville@irisa.fr BenvenisteAlbertalbert.benveniste@irisa.fr GoursatMauricemaurice.goursat@inria.fr MevelLaurentlaurent.mevel@irisa.fr

IRISA, Campus Universitaire de Beaulieu, Rennes Cedex 35042, France

CNRS, Campus Universitaire de Beaulieu, Rennes Cedex 35042, France

INRIA, Campus Universitaire de Beaulieu, Rennes Cedex 35042, France

INRIA, Domaine de Voluceau Rocquencourt, BP 105, Le Chesnay Cedex 78153, France

EURASIP Journal on Advances in Signal Processing 1687-6180 2007 2007 1 069136 http://asp.eurasipjournals.com/content/2007/1/069136 10.1155/2007/69136 222006332006275200616102006 2007Basseville et al.

This paper reports on the theory and practice of covariance-driven output-only and input/output subspace-based identification and detection algorithms. The motivating and investigated application domain is vibration-based structural analysis and health monitoring of mechanical, civil, and aeronautic structures.

Advances in Subspace-Based Techniques for Signal Processing and Communications

[1234567891011121314151617181920212223242526272829303132333435363738394041424344454647484950515253545556575859606162636465666768697071727374757677]

Stochastic theory of minimal realizationAkaïkeHIEEE Transactions on Automatic Control197419666767410.1109/TAC.1974.1100707Markovian representation of stochastic processes by canonical variablesAkaïkeHSIAM Journal on Control and Optimization197513116217310.1137/0313010Structural Health MonitoringLavoisier, Paris, FranceBalageas D, Fritzen C-P, Güemes A2006Neyman-Le Cam tests based on estimating functionsBasawaIProceedings of the Berkeley Conference in Honor of Jerzy Neyman and Jack KieferWadsworth, Belmont, Calif, USALe Cam L, Olshen R19852811825Selected proceedings of the Symposium on Estimating FunctionsInstitute of Mathematical Statistics, Hayward, Calif, USABasawa I, Godambe VP, Taylor R1997Information criteria for residual generation and fault detection and isolationBassevilleMAutomatica199733578380310.1016/S0005-1098(97)00004-6On-board component fault detection and isolation using the statistical local approachBassevilleMAutomatica199834111391141510.1016/S0005-1098(98)00086-7An invariance property of some subspace-based detection algorithmsBassevilleMIEEE Transactions on Signal Processing199947123398340010.1109/78.806083Subspace-based fault detection algorithms for vibration monitoringBassevilleMAbdelghaniMBenvenisteAAutomatica200036110110910.1016/S0005-1098(99)00093-X<it>In situ</it> damage monitoring in vibration mechanics: diagnostics and predictive maintenanceBassevilleMBenvenisteAGach-DevauchelleBMechanical Systems and Signal Processing19937540142310.1006/mssp.1993.1023Output-only subspace-based structural identification: from theory to industrial testing practiceBassevilleMBenvenisteAGoursatMHermansLMevelLvan der AuweraerHJournal of Dynamic Systems, Measurement and Control, Transactions of the ASME20011234668676special issue on identfication of mechanical systems10.1115/1.1410919Handling uncertainties in identification and model validation: a statistical approachBassevilleMBenvenisteAMevelLProceedings of the 24th International Modal Analysis Conference (IMAC '06), January 2006, Saint Louis, Mich, USASEMtutorial paperDetection and diagnosis of changes in the eigenstructure of nonstationary multivariable systemsBassevilleMBenvenisteAMoustakidesGRougéeAAutomatica198723447948910.1016/0005-1098(87)90077-XMultiple CUSUM tests for flutter monitoringBassevilleMGoursatMMevelLProceedings of the 14th Symposium on System Identfication (SYSID '06), March 2006, Newcastle, AustraliaIFAC / IFORS624629Statistical model-based damage detection and localization: subspace-based residuals and damage-to-noise sensitivity ratiosBassevilleMMevelLGoursatMJournal of Sound and Vibration20042753–5769794Output-only subspace-based damage detection—application to a reticular structureBassevilleMMevelLVecchioAPeetersBvan der AuweraerHStructural Health Monitoring20032216116810.1177/1475921703002002008BassevilleMNikiforovIVDetection of Abrupt Changes—Theory and Applications, Information and System Sciences SeriesPrentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, USA1993319890921929756Fault isolation for diagnosis: nuisance rejection and multiple hypothesis testingBassevilleMNikiforovIVAnnual Reviews in Control200226218920210.1016/S1367-5788(02)00029-9Handling nuisance parameters in systems monitoringBassevilleMNikiforovIVProceedings of the 44th IEEE Conference on Decision and Control and European Control Conference (CDC-ECC '05), December 2005, Seville, SpainIEEE & EUCA38323837The asymptotic local approach to change detection and model validationBenvenisteABassevilleMMoustakidesGVIEEE Transactions on Automatic Control198732758359210.1109/TAC.1987.1104683Single sample modal identfication of a non-stationary stochastic processBenvenisteAFuchsJ-JIEEE Transactions on Automatic Control1985301667410.1109/TAC.1985.1103787BenvenisteAMétivierMPriouretPAdaptive Algorithms and Stochastic Approximations, Applications of MathematicsSpringer, New York, NY, USA199022Nonstationary consistency of subspace methodsBenvenisteAMevelLResearch Report 1752IRISA, Rennes, France2005 http://hal.inria.fr/inria-00000869 Nonstationary consistency of subspace methodsBenvenisteAMevelLProceedings of the 44th IEEE Conference on Decision and Control and European Control Conference (CDC-ECC '05), December 2005, Seville, SpainIEEE & EUCA70967101Overview of recent flight flutter testing research at NASA DrydenBrennerMLindRVoracekDTechnical Memorandum NASA TM-4792NASA Dryden, Edwards, Calif, USA1997Invariance of subspace based estimatorsCardosoJ-FMoulinesÉIEEE Transactions on Signal Processing20004892495250510.1109/78.863052Frequency-domain subspace identification using FRF data from arbitrary signalsCaubergheBGuillaumePPintelonRVerbovenPJournal of Sound and Vibration20062903–5555571On the relationship between identfication and local testsDelyonBJuditskyABenvenisteAResearch Report 1104IRISA, Rennes, France1997 http://www.irisa.fr/bibli/publi/pi/1997/1104/1104.html Diagnosing mechanical changes in vibrating systemsDevauchelleBBassevilleMBenvenisteAProceedings of the 1st Symposium on Fault Detection, Supervision and Safety for Technical Processes (SAFEPROCESS '91), September 1991, Baden-Baden, FRG, GermanyIFAC / IMACS159164A summary review of vibration-based damage identification methodsDoeblingSWFarrarCRPrimeMBThe Shock and Vibration Digest19983029110510.1177/058310249803000201EwinsDJModal Testing: Theory, Practice and ApplicationsResearch Studies Press, Letchworth, Hertfordshire, UK22000Vibration-based structural damage identificationFarrarCRDoeblingSWNixDAPhilosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences2001359177813114910.1098/rsta.2000.0717On the achievable accuracy of structural parameter estimatesGerschWJournal of Sound and Vibration1974341637910.1016/S0022-460X(74)80355-XEstimating FunctionsClarendon Press, Oxford, UKGodambe VP1991Recursive output-only subspace identification for in-flight flutter monitoringGoethalsIMevelLBenvenisteAde MoorBProceedings of the 22nd International Modal Analysis Conference (IMAC '04), January 2004, Dearborn, Mich, USASEMOn-line monitoring of bradford stadiumGoursatMMevelLProceedings of the 23rd International Modal Analysis Conference (IMAC '05), January 2005, Orlando, Fla, USASEMOn-line monitoring of the crowd influence on manchester stadiumGoursatMMevelLProceedings of the 24th International Modal Analysis Conference (IMAC '06), January 2006, Saint Louis, Mich, USASEMOn large sample estimation and testing in parametric modelsHallWMathiasonDInternational Statistical Review1990581779710.2307/1403475HeydeCCQuasi-Likelihood and Its Application, Series in StatisticsSpringer, New York, NY, USA1997HeylenWLammensSSasPModal Analysis Theory and TestingDepartment of Mechanical Engineering, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Leuven, Belgium1995Aerodynamic modeling and system identification from flight data—recent applications at DLRJategaonkarRFischenbergDvon GruenhagenWAIAA Journal of Aircraft200441468169110.2514/1.3165JuangJNApplied System IdentificationPrentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, USA1994Diffusion approximation for a pseudo-likelihood test process with application to detection of change in a stochastic systemLadelliLStochastics and Stochastics Reports1990321125Flight testing with the flutterometerLindRJournal of Aircraft200340357457910.2514/2.3132LjungLSystem Identification—Theory for the UserPTR Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ, USA2199922084395MaeckJDamage assessment of civil engineering structures by vibration monitoring, Ph.D. thesisDepartment of Civil Engineering, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Leuven, Belgium2003MarchMc LeishDLSmallCGThe Theory and Application of Statistical Inference Functions, Lecture Notes in StatisticsSpringer, Berlin, Germany198844Subspace-based multivariable system identification from frequency response dataMcKelveyTAkcayHLjungLIEEE Transactions on Automatic Control199641796097910.1109/9.508900Fast in-flight detection of flutter onset: a statistical approachMevelLBassevilleMBenvenisteAAIAA Journal of Guidance, Control, and Dynamics200528343143810.2514/1.6184Merging sensor data from multiple measurement set-ups for non-stationary subspace-based modal analysisMevelLBassevilleMBenvenisteAGoursatMJournal of Sound and Vibration2002249471974110.1006/jsvi.2001.3880Stochastic subspace-based structural identification and damage detection—application to the steel-quake benchmarkMevelLBassevilleMGoursatMMechanical Systems and Signal Processing20031719110110.1006/mssp.2002.1544Input/output versus output-only data processing for structural identification—application to in-flight data analysisMevelLBenvenisteABassevilleMJournal of Sound and Vibration2006295353155210.1016/j.jsv.2006.01.039Blind subspace-based eigenstructure identification under nonstationary excitation using moving sensorsMevelLBenvenisteABassevilleMGoursatMIEEE Transactions on Signal Processing2002501414810.1109/78.972480On-line monitoring of slow to fast evolving aeronautic structuresMevelLCoursatMBassevilleMBenvenisteAProceedings of the International Conference on Noise and Vibration Engineering (ISMA '04), September 2004, Leuven, Belgium10331047Model validation by using a damage detection testMevelLGoursatMProceedings of the 24th International Modal Analysis Conference (IMAC '06), January 2006, Saint Louis, Mich, USASEMStochastic subspace-based structural identification and damage detection and localisation—application to the Z24 bridge benchmarkMevelLGoursatMBassevilleMMechanical Systems and Signal Processing200317114315110.1006/mssp.2002.1552Subspace-based modal identification and monitoring of large structures, a Scilab toolboxMevelLGoursatMBassevilleMBenvenisteAProceedings of the 13th Symposium on System identification (SYSID '03), August 2003, Rotterdam, The NetherlandsIFAC / IFORS14051410 http://www.irisa.fr/sisthem/cosmad/ On the application of a subspace-based fault detection method to industrial structuresMevelLHermansLvan der AuweraerHMechanical Systems and Signal Processing199913682383810.1006/mssp.1999.1247The problem of diagnosis with respect to physical parameters for changes in structuresMoustakidesGResearch Report 295IRISA, Rennes, France1986Diagnosing mechanical changes in vibrating systemsMoustakidesGBassevilleMBenvenisteAVeyGLResearch Report 436IRISA, Rennes, France1988Detecting changes in the AR parameters of a nonstationary ARMA processMoustakidesGBenvenisteAStochastics19861613715510.1080/17442508608833370Analysis of subspace fitting and ML techniques for parameter estimation from sensor array dataOtterstenBVibergMKailathTIEEE Transactions on Signal Processing199240359060010.1109/78.120802Reference-based stochastic subspace identification for output-only modal analysisPeetersBDe RoeckGMechanical Systems and Signal Processing199913685587810.1006/mssp.1999.1249Stochastic system identification for operational modal analysis: a reviewPeetersBDe RoeckGJournal of Dynamic Systems, Measurement and Control, Transactions of the ASME20011234659667special issue on identification of mechanical systems10.1115/1.1410370Vibration-based damage detection in civil engineering: excitation sources and temperature effectsPeetersBMaeckJDe RoeckGSmart Materials and Structures200110351852710.1088/0964-1726/10/3/314Online vibration-based crack detection during fatigue testingPeetersBMevelLVanlanduitSKey Engineering Materials20032452571578Flight flutter testing of transport aircraft: in-flight modal analysisPickrelCWhitePProceedings of the 21st International Modal Analysis Conference (IMAC '03), February 2003, Kissimmee, Fla, USASEMOptimum robust detection of changes in the AR part of a multivariable ARMA processRougéeABassevilleMBenvenisteAMoustakidesGIEEE Transactions on Automatic Control198732121116112010.1109/TAC.1987.1104500StoïcaPMosesRLIntroduction to Spectral AnalysisPrentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ, USA1997Van OverscheePDe MoorBSubspace Identification for Linear SystemsKluwer Academic, Boston, Mass, USA1996Subspace-based methods for the identification of linear time-invariant systemsVibergMAutomatica199531121835185310.1016/0005-1098(95)00107-5Sensor array processing based on subspace fittingVibergMOtterstenBIEEE Transactions on Signal Processing19913951110112110.1109/78.80966Analysis of state space system identification methods based on instrumental variables and subspace fittingVibergMWahlbergBOtterstenBAutomatica19973391603161610.1016/S0005-1098(97)00097-6A multi-input modal parameter estimation algorithm for mini-computersVoldHKundratJRocklinTRusselRSAE Transaction1982911815821SAE paper 820194Advanced numerical computation of <inline-formula><graphic file="1687-6180-2007-069136-i1.gif"/></inline-formula>-tests for fault detection and isolationZhangQBassevilleMProceedings of the 5th Symposium on Fault Detection, Supervision and Safety for Technical Processes (SAFEPROCESS '03), June 2003, Washington, DC, USAIFAC / IMACS211216Early warning of slight changes in systemsZhangQBassevilleMBenvenisteAAutomatica19943019511310.1016/0005-1098(94)90231-3Structural health monitoring using vibration measurements and engineering insightZimmermanDCKaoukMSimmermacherTJournal of Mechanical Design, Transactions of the ASME1995117 B214221