Make Kitsch the Enemy: The “Monstrous Carbuncle” of the UK’s Vetting and Barring Scheme

Abstract : In architecture, the primacy of function over form was one of the core tenets of the Bauhaus School of Design. In Information Systems, function is critical, yet so many systems fail to deliver hoped for benefits. Badly designed, acquired imitatively for their symbolic, magical power, they represent a form of kitsch. To illustrate this, we describe a major national IS initiative in the UK, the Vetting and Barring Scheme (VBS). Set up to ensure that only “suitable” adults would ever work with children and vulnerable adults, the Scheme became subject to increasing criticism for its intrusiveness and illiberality, and was suspended at the point of implementation in 2010. Here we expose the kitsch-ness of the Scheme as a meretricious imitation of the sort of diagnostic test used in medicine. We show how its inevitable dysfunctions outweighed its hypothetical benefits, which were largely magical and symbolic in nature. That the VBS attracted such little critical comment from IS scholars is significant, suggesting two biases (pro-business and pro-technology) in IS research which should be put right. We argue that kitsch can be combatted by practising design along principles akin to those of the Bauhaus. Our field can contribute to this, but our infatuation with theory, in itself a form of kitsch science, stands in the way of a closer relationship with practice.
Type de document :
Communication dans un congrès
Markus Nüttgens; Andreas Gadatsch; Karlheinz Kautz; Ingrid Schirmer; Nadine Blinn. Governance and Sustainability in Information Systems: Managing the Transfer and Diffusion of IT (Working conference), Sep 2011, Hamburg, Germany. Springer, IFIP Advances in Information and Communication Technology, AICT-366, pp.105-118, 2011, Governance and Sustainability in Information Systems. Managing the Transfer and Diffusion of IT. 〈10.1007/978-3-642-24148-2_7〉
Liste complète des métadonnées

Littérature citée [22 références]  Voir  Masquer  Télécharger

https://hal.inria.fr/hal-01571744
Contributeur : Hal Ifip <>
Soumis le : jeudi 3 août 2017 - 14:34:13
Dernière modification le : vendredi 1 décembre 2017 - 01:16:39

Fichier

978-3-642-24148-2_7_Chapter.pd...
Fichiers produits par l'(les) auteur(s)

Licence


Distributed under a Creative Commons Paternité 4.0 International License

Identifiants

Citation

David Wastell, Sue White. Make Kitsch the Enemy: The “Monstrous Carbuncle” of the UK’s Vetting and Barring Scheme. Markus Nüttgens; Andreas Gadatsch; Karlheinz Kautz; Ingrid Schirmer; Nadine Blinn. Governance and Sustainability in Information Systems: Managing the Transfer and Diffusion of IT (Working conference), Sep 2011, Hamburg, Germany. Springer, IFIP Advances in Information and Communication Technology, AICT-366, pp.105-118, 2011, Governance and Sustainability in Information Systems. Managing the Transfer and Diffusion of IT. 〈10.1007/978-3-642-24148-2_7〉. 〈hal-01571744〉

Partager

Métriques

Consultations de la notice

300

Téléchargements de fichiers

14