An empirical evaluation of free BEM solvers for M/EEG forward modeling

Abstract : Neuroimaging with magneto and electroencephalography (M/EEG) requires to compute the forward problem. It consists in predicting what is measured by MEG or EEG sensors due to a configuration of current generators within the head. When considering realistic head models, the equations derived from Maxwell equations can only be solved numerically. The Boundary Element Method is a standard approach to address this problem. However, different mathematical and computational variants exist within this class of BEM solvers. At least two BEM formulations exist for M/EEG forward modeling [Geselowitz 1967, Kybic et al. 2005]. Also implementation details vary between the different software packages (e.g. the precision of the numerical integrations). In order to investigate the influence of such differences, we have conducted a numerical experiment that evaluates the precision of different freely available BEM solvers. The BEM solvers are tested for EEG forward modeling with head models consisting of three nested shells. Multiple dipoles are located at different distances from the inner shell supposed to model the inner skull. To quantify the precision of the solvers we consider sphere models for which analytical solutions exist. Random sphere models are obtained by triangulating points randomly sampled over the spheres. We test and compare the accuracy of the BEM solvers on multiple random sphere models with different numbers of vertices on each interface. We also provide the computation times of the different solvers. The implementations tested are: OpenMEEG, SimBio [Zanow et al. 1995], Helsinki BEM [Stenroos et al. 2007], Dipoli [Oostendorp et al. 1989] and BEMCP [Phillips 2000] (Dipoli and BEMCP are available via Fieldtrip or SPM). Results show that OpenMEEG provides the best accuracy, followed by SimBio and dipoli which give comparable results. Finally, BEMCP and Helsinki BEM provide rather limited precisions.
Type de document :
Biomag, May 2010, Dubrovnik, Croatia. 2010
Liste complète des métadonnées

Littérature citée [2 références]  Voir  Masquer  Télécharger
Contributeur : Alexandre Gramfort <>
Soumis le : mardi 15 janvier 2013 - 23:06:01
Dernière modification le : vendredi 12 janvier 2018 - 11:01:54
Document(s) archivé(s) le : mardi 16 avril 2013 - 04:02:19


Fichiers produits par l'(les) auteur(s)


  • HAL Id : hal-00776674, version 1



Alexandre Gramfort, Théodore Papadopoulo, Emmanuel Olivi, Maureen Clerc. An empirical evaluation of free BEM solvers for M/EEG forward modeling. Biomag, May 2010, Dubrovnik, Croatia. 2010. 〈hal-00776674〉



Consultations de la notice


Téléchargements de fichiers