In Defense of Merit in Science

D. Abbot; A. Bikfalvi; A.L. Bleske-Rechek; W. Bodmer; P. Boghossian; C.M. Carvalho; J. Ciccolini; J.A. Coyne; J. Gauss; P.M.W. Gill; S. Jitomirskaya; L. Jussim; A.I. Krylov; G.C. Loury; L. Maroja; J.H. Mcwhorter; S. Moosavi; P. Nayna Schwerdtle; J. Pearl; M.A. Quintanilla-Tornel; H.F. Schaefer Iii; P.R. Schreiner; P. Schwerdtfeger; D. Shechtman; M. Shifman; J. Tanzman; B.L. Trout; A. Warshel; J.D. West

doi:10.35995/jci03010001

Journal Articles Journal of Controversial Ideas Year : 2023

In Defense of Merit in Science

, , , , , , (1) , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

D. Abbot

Function : Author

A. Bikfalvi

Function : Author

A.L. Bleske-Rechek

Function : Author

W. Bodmer

Function : Author

P. Boghossian

Function : Author

C.M. Carvalho

Function : Author

J. Ciccolini

Function : Author

Méthodes computationnelles pour la prise en charge thérapeutique en oncologie : Optimisation des stratégies par modélisation mécaniste et statistique

J.A. Coyne

Function : Author

J. Gauss

Function : Author

P.M.W. Gill

Function : Author

S. Jitomirskaya

Function : Author

L. Jussim

Function : Author

A.I. Krylov

Function : Author

G.C. Loury

Function : Author

L. Maroja

Function : Author

J.H. Mcwhorter

Function : Author

S. Moosavi

Function : Author

P. Nayna Schwerdtle

Function : Author

J. Pearl

Function : Author

M.A. Quintanilla-Tornel

Function : Author

H.F. Schaefer Iii

Function : Author

P.R. Schreiner

Function : Author

P. Schwerdtfeger

Function : Author

D. Shechtman

Function : Author

M. Shifman

Function : Author

J. Tanzman

Function : Author

B.L. Trout

Function : Author

A. Warshel

Function : Author

J.D. West

Function : Author

Abstract

Merit is a central pillar of liberal epistemology, humanism, and democracy. The scientific enterprise, built on merit, has proven effective in generating scientific and technological advances, reducing suffering, narrowing social gaps, and improving the quality of life globally. This perspective documents the ongoing attempts to undermine the core principles of liberal epistemology and to replace merit with non-scientific, politically motivated criteria. We explain the philosophical origins of this conflict, document the intrusion of ideology into our scientific institutions, discuss the perils of abandoning merit, and offer an alternative, human-centered approach to address existing social inequalities.

Domains

Life Sciences [q-bio]

Joseph Ciccolini : Connect in order to contact the contributor

https://hal.science/hal-04352297

Submitted on : Tuesday, December 19, 2023-8:30:21 AM

Last modification on : Wednesday, December 20, 2023-8:48:48 AM

Dates and versions

hal-04352297 , version 1 (19-12-2023)

Identifiers

HAL Id : hal-04352297 , version 1
DOI : 10.35995/jci03010001

Cite

D. Abbot, A. Bikfalvi, A.L. Bleske-Rechek, W. Bodmer, P. Boghossian, et al.. In Defense of Merit in Science. Journal of Controversial Ideas, 2023, 3 (1), pp.1. ⟨10.35995/jci03010001⟩. ⟨hal-04352297⟩

Export

BibTeX XML-TEI Dublin Core DC Terms EndNote DataCite

Collections

CNRS INRIA UNIV-AMU INRIA2 CRCM

134 View

0 Download

In Defense of Merit in Science

Abstract

Domains

Dates and versions

Identifiers

Cite

Export

Collections

Altmetric

Share